"Plato initiated our negative view of the written word by arguing that writing was merely an imitation of speech... while speech was an imitation of thought. Thus writing would be an imitation of an imitation."
Andrew Feenberg: The written world.

Tuesday, December 21

lurking, reasons why

Here is a 42-page PDF which I may skim over the main points at a later date: Reasons why lurkers don't post:

- shy about posting
- want to remain anonymous
- posting is of no value to me
- messages or group low quality
- wrong group
- long delay getting response
- concern about aggressive responses
- fear of commitment
- new members treated poorly
- nothing to offer (22%)
- others have said it
- still learning about the group (29%)
- had no intention of posting
- no requirement to post
- just reading/browsing is enough (53%)
- not enough time
- do not know how to post
- too many messages

Below are more reasons which people may choose to lurk. It is from an interesting research project by Jacquie McDonald and colleagues (12-page MSWord).

- feel generally happy with outcomes and are learning/sharing in their own ways
- wish to hoard their information
- fear (of losing face, letting their colleagues down, or misleading them)
- are in the listening and learning stages
- think it’s not polite to interrupt or to “speak and run”
- have external time constraints
- feel it meets their learning needs, their level of commitment, and schedule needs
- feel keeping relevant requires recent involvement in online dialogue, so sporadic attendance or absence leads to lurking
- some people are naturally cautious or slow to react
- feel that participation is not a priority
- feel that a genuine invitation has not been extended to allow them to participate at the core
- struggle with language
- lost and overwhelmed and don’t want to say so
- the community may feel impermeable
- the practice may be too hard for just anyone to master
- may just want to check out the community
- may have had off-putting experiences when first encountering the community
- may be cultural or personality issues at play that are not visible even to the lurker
- shy away from any responsibility
- inability to identify with the community members

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home